This TGC Australia article seems to be making waves. In it, the author argues, using his own experience that spouses should not prioritise sitting together as family units in church. Instead, he argues that they should split up in order to sit with other people in the church, particularly looking out for those on their own. He aims to sit with single men whilst his wife watches out for single women.
Some people seem to have shared this giving strong support. Others have reacted strongly the other way. A bit of a backlash is forming. Indeed, I’ve seen suggestions that the post represents an attack on family itself. I think this is to misunderstand the nature of the article. I could be wrong but I read it as a deliberately provocative piece. I am not completely convinced by his argument, and would have a number of concerns that I’m not going to get into here, I certainly don’t think we should make his and his wife’s approach a law but I do think it should provoke us to think about how we approach welcome and care in our churches.
If we should not make his approach into a law, we also should not make a law against it. If we assume that church assemblies must be in family units then we might be making one cultural approach at a given time in history into the law. In some cultures at different times, men and women would have sat separately. Indeed, this may well have been the case in some NT contexts.
However, just because an approach is appropriate to some cultural contexts does not mean it is always right. Some churches may consider it important not to segregate the sexes because of what that might say to their culture about their attitude to male and female equality.
So, don’t make it a rule but also don’t prohibit it. There have been times when for various reasons, Sarah and I have not been able to sit together in church and times when we have chosen not to because we wanted to prioritise other needs. This isn’t a negative statement about family. We do much together throughout the week.
Other churches and individuals have been discussing how they approach things. I actually think that is a potentially healthy response as it gets us thinking. I saw one church describe how they encourage families to sit together for much of the gathering but also to include single people in their family group. This is a good instinctive and can be beneficial to the single person and to the family. Again, don’t make this a law and rule out the TGC option. There may be reasons as to why a single person might struggle with sitting with families. There may also be safeguarding factors that in some cases mean it is not appropriate.
I would encourage churches and church leaders to take a look at the article, not to either dismiss it or implement it wholesale but rather “chew the meat and spit out the bones.”[1] What can we learn from it for our church? How are we doing at care for families and care for singles? How can we be more welcoming?
[1] The term I learnt from Terry Virgo via Andy Johnston.