How do you counsel someone who has gone through bereavement? There can be a tendency to assume that bereavement will follow a standard pattern. We assume a person will go through a series of emotions, shock, denial, anger, guilt, acceptance. We put timescales on it and we look for basic counselling answers.
However, bereavement isn’t always tidy. The sudden death of a loved one at an unexpected time is different to death in old age, different again to death from a lengthy illness. Loss of a parent hits differently to loss of a spouse, lose of a friend, different again and loss of a child including through still birth or miscarriage should not be underestimated. And there is something important, we can assume that some deaths are weighty and others not. All bereavement carries a weightiness even if we carry that differently in different circumstances.
We can also have some assumptions about counselling too. Back in the middle of the 20th Century, Jay E Adams was resisting an assumption that therapy could replace pastoral counselling and discipleship. The biblical Counselling movement arose out of this. I write as someone who appreciates that movement. However, there is a risk that we then start to treat the Bible as therapy. Actually, yes, there is something therapeutic in the broadests sense. Applying the Gospel to all of our lives is healing. However Scripture isn’t just a therapists’ source book.
And I think that there was a risk with Biblical and Christian counselling movements. The risk was that they missed on the possibility that there is benefit from therapy and that benefit isn’t dependent on finding a Christian to provide it.
Sometimes, I’m asked if I can recommend a Christian counsellor. The first reality is that in the UK there isn’t the same kind of Christian or Biblical Counselling infrastructure that there is in the US, so I might not be able to identify someone. In fact, whilst I know Christians who work in different aspects of therapy, they sdon’t tend to be claiming to be offering a Christian methodology. They simply happen to be believers working in a profession. On a side note, I should ass that I’ve accessed therapy in a couple of contexts. First, years ago through work when seeking to manage stress and secondly, as adoptive parents, we have both had some training in therapeutic parenting and with our children access a play and art therapist.
When I’m asked to recommend, I usually ask the person to tell me a little more about the context. You see, context matters. Sometimes I suggest that what is needed is pastoral care m the church, something that can be provided best through church members and the pastor. What they are looking for at the time is someone to pray with them and open God’s Word with them. That’s what pastors are equipped and called to do.
On other occasions I encourage them to prioritise finding a therapist. What matters at this point is not whether or not the therapist is a Christian but whether they have expertise in the particular area that is needed. For example, for the person who has suffered loss of a baby through still birth, the priority is not to find a Christian with a general awareness of bereavement. Rather, they need someone who can give specialist care for bably loss and indeed has an understanding of the impact of trauma too.Once that person is found, the church can scaffold around the person with love, practical support and God’s Word.
We should be careful that our presumptions about grief, therapy and Christianity don’t lead to a one size fits all approach.