Apparently, King Charles has left a lot of people deeply vexed by his General Synod address. He argued that the Church of England exists to safeguard “not just the Christian faith… but the very space for faith itself — of every belief — within our whole society and national discourse.” One person, actually calling himself the vexed vicar has gone so far as to call the King a heretic.[1]
Should we be equally vexed and appalled. Well maybe but to be honest this isn’t something that is going to get me worked up. Let me explain why. We have to remember five things. First, in contrast to his mum, I don’t think we have evidence to say that the King is anything more than a nominal Christian. Elizabeth II and Queen Victoria were the exceptions, not the norm. We know that faith cannot be inherited, even if the Crown can be which is why it seems a little unwise to make responsibility for defending the faith hereditary also.
Secondly, the title “Defender of the Faith” was originally given to King Henry VIII for attacking Protestantism. Henry decided to hang onto the title once he jumped ship. So in fact, the original title was nothing to do with defending the Gospel and everything to do with protecting Catholicism.
Thirdly, King Charles was speaking to the established church, the CofE. Now, it is worth observing two things. First, as an institution, the CofE is a long way from defending the Gospel, it is a compromise of different versions of Christianity. I’m not going to get worked up about the King saying things to the Church of England that I wouldn’t say to our church. Secondly, I don’t think that having an established church is a good thing. That’s part of why I’m not an Anglican. My trust is in God, he is the one who is our protector.
Fourthly, some of those getting worked up are the very people arguing for a Christian Nation. Yet Charles was simply restating a well known argument for Christian nations. The argument is that such nations offer tolerance to those of other faiths so that people do have the space to live alongside each other. If it is okay for them to argue that a Muslim is better off under Christian government that Islamic government then surely it is okay for Charles to argue that the church provides space for Muslims. Now, you may have issues with both the premise and whether it works but it is important to be consistent.
Fifth and most importantly, I don’t think our responsibility as Christians and churches, distinct from the CofE is to defend Christianity. Our job is to proclaim the Gospel. Instead of worrying about what the King said to one group of people, we should focus on what we are saying and doing. Are we speaking for Christ?