Internal or external temptation

Photo by Seda Nur Korkmaz on Pexels.com

In his comments responding To John Samuel’s letter in Evangelicals Now, Matthew Roberts writes:  

“True, purely external temptation does not make us guilty of sin, just as it did not for Christ. But for the rest of us external temptation is joined by the internal temptation of our sinful hearts. “Each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire” (James 1v14), which emphatically was not true of Christ. And since it is a sin to tempt (which is why God tempts no-one, James 1v13; see also Luke 17v1,2) the desire to sin is sin. It pollutes our hearts, makes us an offence to God in our deepest being (Ps.51v5-6) and lies at the root of the sinfulness of all sinful actions. It was Paul’s covetous desire which condemned him before God, and the realisation of it which God used to bring him to conviction and repentance (Rom.7v7-12). That is why repentance must not be merely external like the Pharisees, but internal. It is tearing our hearts, not our garments (Joel 2v13); grieving not merely that we did evil, but that we are evil, in the depths of our hearts, from where our sins come (Mark 7v20-23).

Picking up on the last comment first, I think that’s theologically and pastorally messy.  Yes, we were “evil, in the depth of our hearts”, yes there is the sense of an ongoing internal battle in Romans 7-8, there are things to put to death within us.  However, it is quite the category error to make this statement about believers who are a new creation, are justified and have their identity in Christ with a new heart.  I say messy not so much because of that objective Biblical point.  The biblical evidence just makes Robert’s position wrong.  It’s messy because of the confusion related to Robert’s resistance to people including their struggles in their identification, such as with Same-Sex Attraction. We also need to be careful that we do not slip into a prosperity Gospel type approach with regards to our desires.  It is true that someone might struggle with addictions.  Some might experience immediate or sudden release from an addiction to nicotine or alcohol.  Others do not.  Incidentally I wonder how Roberts would pastorally engage with the person who comes to him and says  “Can you provide grape juice at communion because I am an alcoholic”.

However, in this article I wanted to turn to something else.  I’m specifically interested in what Roberts does with internal temptation.   I think there is a further category confusion here.   He adds full personal identity to our desires.  He says that to tempt is to sin and therefore when I’m tempted by my own desires them the desire sins by tempting me and so I sin.  This fails to give proper weight to Romans 7:13-21 which explicitly acknowledges tension and distinguishes between what I desire or will and sin, likened by John Stevens to “an alien interloper”. 

So, we need to be very careful about how we describe the believer.  Sin is itself offensive to God, indwelling sin is offensive and there is an offensiveness about our fallen nature.  However, our identity in Christ means that through his death, we have been reconciled to God, our past, present and future sin is forgiven, covered over.  We are justified, right with God.   “There is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. (Romans 8:1).  A challenge throughout history has been to encourage growth and sanctification whilst not over turning grace.  The way to do that is through how Romans 8 handles the challenge.

Roberts wishes to make a distinction between external temptation for which we are not culpable and internal for which we are.   He argues that Jesus was only subjected to “external temptation”.   However, it is worth noting that this is not something the Bible says and nor does it suggest that his innocence was found in the fact that he did not experience internal temptation.  Rather, it is found in the fact that although tempted in every way he was without sin.  Hebrews uses of “in every way” is instructive.  It is unlikely to mean that Jesus experienced every single category of temptation but that the nature of temptation was to the same degree and depth. 

I think what we see here is a common error.  We identify something as so and we recognise that it would be repugnant if true of God, so we decide that therefore we cannot say certain things about Jesus.  We should approach things from the other angle.   What does the Bible actually teach us about Jesus?  Then that will help us to describe and define our doctrines correctly to avoid error.

We know that Jesus when he was in the Garden was not just resisting external pressure when he asked for the cup to pass from him.  There was a genuine desire not to go through intense suffering and shame.  In the Wilderness, Jesus was genuinely hungry and weary.  The tempter deliberately seeks to work with Jesus’ internal experience.

This takes us to a further problem.  Roberts has collapsed  the human experience in to one thing.  The reality is that we experience common desires for identity, comfort and security.  Those desires are in and of themselves good.  However, desire can become disordered.   This is the crucial difference between Jesus and me.  Temptation works through my disordered desire, his desires were not disordered.  However, the tempter still sought to use those desires so that the temptation was in response to what was happening within.

So I think there is a reason why Robert’s approach leaves us pastorally unsatisfied.  I frequently argue here that what we believe affects how we live.  Roberts’ account of the doctrine of humanity and of Christ’s humanity is unsatisfying and that’s why the pastoral follow on is unsatisfying too.